Community Plan Project
First Community Forum
Thursday, October 26, 2000
7:00. - 9:00 P.M.
High School Cafeteria
Transcription of Input Received from the Community
Introduction. Picking up where the Spring 2000 Survey left off, the purpose of the Fall 2000 Forum was to work toward agreement on what Belchertown’s planning should try to accomplish. More than 160 members of the community attended and participated in the Fall Forum.
Initial Brainstorming. The Forum began with a review of some of the highlights from the Survey, working from a handout [copy attached]. Then participants brainstormed a few initial responses to the following questions:
In what specific ways does Belchertown look rural?
Which are the most important to our town’s special character?
Specifically how does Belchertown feel rural?
What are the positive ways that Belchertown functions like a small town?
Initial thoughts about how Belchertown looks rural were:
Open spaces Farms Working forests Views of open spaces from roads Quaint Town Common Low density |
Light traffic Traditional New England architecture Wildlife Unusual houses No grocery store Stone walls Horses/cows Uncrowded roads |
Initial thoughts about how Belchertown feels rural were:
|
Friendly: people know your name Safety Quiet, deserted Civility |
Good air/water People involved in government Know most parents of the children your children play with |
Initial thoughts about how Belchertown functions like a rural town were:
Community involvement Personal touch to Town services Open Town Meeting "Low tax rate" Churches |
Trust – seal with a handshake Town Fair and parades Compassion Local business support Know the police officers |
Participants then brainstormed initial responses to the question,
What change would signal to you that Belchertown has lost
the "rural" character that you value?
Initial thoughts were:
|
Loss of farms, open space |
Big schools |
|
More housing [subdivisions] |
Too many stores |
|
Court House |
Chain stores |
|
Heavy industry |
Loss of lakes |
|
Traffic |
Infringement upon private property |
|
Less friendly |
Increased traffic from commercial areas |
|
Not knowing the neighbors Not knowing your children’s friends’ parents |
Increased cut through traffic on side roads Widening roads Apartment complexes |
|
Not allowing dogs in the Library |
Small setbacks from road |
|
Malls [rather than individual stores] |
Loss of "vision" – view of open space along roads |
|
Lower quality environment [pollution of water, light and noise pollution] |
Lack of recreation area that have access to [hiking] |
Discussion in Small Groups. Participants then broke into discussion groups as randomly assigned through numbers on their nametags. Each group had a recorder recruited in advance by the Steering Committee. Many thanks are due the recorders, who were:
|
Barbara Schaeffer-Bacon [#1] Dan Beaudette [#2} Mike Reardon [#3] Richard White [#4] Kathy Beresky [#5] Kirk Stephens [#6] |
Cliff McCarthy [#7] Tibby Chase [#8] Linda Barron [#9] Mary Ellen O’Reilley-Bracey [#10] Joe Gilman [#11] Sue Gay [#12] |
Jim Natle [#13] Ron Akins [#14] Rosanne Martoccia [#15] Gary Brougham [#16] Gail Grammarossa [#17 & 18] Ron Aponte [#19] |
A third of the groups started with question set #1, a third started with #2, and the rest started with #3 to make sure that each set of questions received full attention by at least some groups. Recorders put an asterisk next to points on which there was general agreement in the group. The discussion questions were:
1. Specifically what do businesses contribute to town life?
Describe the types of businesses that would support town life.
Where might they best be located?
2. Specifically what do homes contribute to town life?
Since there will be more homes built in Belchertown, describe the types of
new homes that would contribute to town life.
3. What do we mean by "open space"?
Specifically what does it contribute to town life?
What do you think are the most important open spaces for Belchertown’s
future?
What business contributes to town life
Group #1
Convenience
Construction business is big in Belchertown; take care of it
Jobs
Supports tax base
Build community by connecting people to people
Job options: including home based business
Office in homes are new features – more taxes
Small business have accountability – deal with real people – personal
Jobs for kids
Donations to community efforts.
Group #2
Resources [taxes, jobs, community support]
Character of town
Tourism brings in business
Group #3
***Jobs, taxes but you can have negative affects.
***Lower taxes
Depends on the type of business if locally owned, get involved as sponsors
If we could get light industry, more income for citizens
Should cut down on traffic, if live where you work
Services, the saving from travel, opportunity to relate to other people, relationships
Group #4
Taxes, work opportunities, convenience, stability, center
Keep you from driving out of town, supplies, civic pride,
Foodstuffs, ability to own your own business – self-sustaining
Group #5
Convenience, stability
Employment, keeps tax revenues in town
Great schools
Tax base, employment
Convenience, tax relief
Employment opportunities for our High School students
Support tax base, provide conveniences for everyday needs
Group #6
Business in town connection with each other – continuity
Tax base
Group #7
*Tax base [Negatives: pollution, noise, traffic
Self-sufficiency chains taking away autonomous economy]
Services
Convenience
Employment
Group #8
Helps non-profits, local townspeople
Tax base
Jobs to kids
Convenience
Add to quality of life
Locally owned add to the town
Group #9
* Taxes and employment [Negatives: Unnecessary goods &services
Needed goods and services pollution, noise, traffic, light (signs, parking Supporting local organizations lot lighting)
w/ money, goods, supplies & services
Group #10
Service: restaurant, medical facility, accounting
Convenience
Boost tax revenue
Boost quality of life
Support local teams & limited employment
Sense of community
Breakup character of town to define difference sections
Pay taxes, buy and sell locally made goods
Convenience, ambassador to town
Friendliness
Businesses – no tax break to residential
Group #11
Contributes to economy and tax base
Residents can conduct business here
May contribute to cultural life of community
Can contribute to social life if set up right
Claim contribute to tax base, but skeptical
Employment opportunities
Group #12
Businesses support each other, and attract other businesses
Variety – restaurants
More choices, not big boxes
Variety – Mom & Pop type
Competition
Supports town events
Support sports programs
Tax base
Enhances sense of community
Group #13
* Taxes
Convenience
Group #14
Provide jobs
Help tax base
Reduce commuting
Keep people in town, know each other, support local business
Small business around Common create personalization, rural flavor
Decrease stress from forgetting something
Small business promote community
Social activity creates community, creates opportunity to enjoy yourself while
contributing to community, like a recreational activity
Local business people more familiar, personal, and interactive
Group #15
*** Convenience [reasonable]
** Tax base
Employment
Group #16
Save travel [Negative: congestion]
Jobs
Tax base
Local folks
Community development
Groups #17 & #18
Convenience
Tax base
Money
Sense of community – bump into friends while using businesses
Group #19
# Taxes and money to town
Additional tax base alleviates pressure to sell existing open spaces
Types of businesses that would support town life
Group #1
Cultural, educational opportunities
Business to serve youth – recreation
Movie theater near town center
Agriculture, animal, orchard, garden-based business
Clustered business off main roads, but convenient,
e.g. mini-business parks on roads that connect with main through roads.
Home storefronts, e.g. antiques
Owner operated
Ecologically sustainable
Variety of food choices, conveniently
Unique businesses
Support services for seniors
Group #2
* Clean business
* small craft-type business, service [shops]
High tech
Light industry
Tourism
Group #3
*Supermarket – make life easier, reduce travel, checker-type jobs for youth, elderly
* First class restaurant, not fast food
* Hardware store
** Farming
** Logging
* Light industry – higher than minimum wage
Locally owned business
Just the basic, services, glass repair, no malls
Group #4
*Grocery store
*Farms
Anything but industry
Timber industry
Things that generate local
Environmentally friendly business, avoiding global warming
Think tanks
Environmental power supply-type business
Potential for all types; key is not to say "no" but rather say [for example]
heavy manufacturing if meets certain standards
Should have done prison, one worked well in the community I used to live in
Wind to solar business, fuel cells
High tech, software development
Recycling is industry
Group #5
Motel, service business, repair places
Small prefab shops, good clean businesses
Restaurants and areas for socialization
Retail
Supermarket, motel, banks, auto service stations, restaurants
Village shops, theater, restaurants in a cluster such as So. Hadley Common
Light industrial/manufacturing
Community cluster of shops at State School, and to attract out of towners
Group #6
*Don’t lure in undesirable business for tax dollars
Gear to needs of town, not luring in outside people for revenue
Careful of what kind, i.e. environmental concerns, traffic
Town large enough to support lot of varied business: encourage small business
Kinds needed by most people in town
Light manufacturing, technology – attract more
Commercial
Group #7
* Local services: grocery, florist, auto shop, hardware, farm stands, barbershop,
farm supply, pet supply
health care: doctors, dentist, pharmacy, health/fitness
food services
Bed & Breakfasts
Day care
Gift shops, specialty shops
Group #8
**Stop & Shop
* Small business
Laundry, bakery, restaurant
No more large
Not lots of commercial
Small retail
Small manufacturing
Group #9
* Locally owned, non-national corporate insurance company
* Farm stands, forest products
Light industry
Shopping center
Decentralized
Smaller shops; smaller groups
Family restaurants
Small movie theater
Group #10
*Privately owned non chain service community. Keep money in town
Small, service, restaurants
Family-owned small businesses
Bake shops, sport shops
Grocery store
R&D in small business
Farm businesses
Farm stands
Businesses to support arts
Group #11
Why would major business come here?
Make new and existing business look New England, character that the town wants
How much effort, really, has been applied. Belchertown not business-friendly.
Need to open up our view of what is business. Formula of ratio of business to
residential. We are missing the boat. People only want "Mom & Pop".
Palmer project took 10 years to fill.
Want locally owned service type/not industry, trucks, etc.
The organic farm on Jackson Street
Don’t want business that takes away from rural character.
Group #12
Stores to sponsor sports
Locally owned ones – franchise or not
Arts & music [play house]
Performing arts – not stadium
Small industry – technical?
For children’s future help tax base
More jobs
Service oriented – mission
Educational – serve community
Retirement community
Industrial parks – wooded
Medical center – small
Infrastructure
Group #13
*Light manufacturing/high tech
Market gardening, Atkins, Randalls, help to keep farms
Business to draw tourists
Resort, B&B
Quabbin
Limit on square footage for business, e.g. big box retailers
Would not support franchise business
Group #14
Individually owned businesses
Small retail and service variety
Small software company, civil engineering professional service
Retirement community
Office park
Mixed use
Art galleries, photography, rail trail
Public sector buildings
Eco-tourism
Auto dealership
Bicycle shop, used sporting equipment, pet stuff
Toy store, Mexican restaurant, used children clothing store, coffee shop
Group #15
* Grocery store [convenience]
* Service/professional business ex/ MD, lawyer, dentists
Post Office
Affordable family restaurant e.g. 99 in Eastfield Mall
Bank
Hot dog stand
Consignment store
Carriage/stagecoach museum
Group #16
* Building restrictions: use old or existing buildings
* Well planned
* No free ports
Tech-based companies
High tech and research
Arts & crafts
Small shops
Food store
No parking lots like football fields
Not intrusive to quality of life
Clean business
Farmers market
Groups #17 and #18
***** Keep local business and support them
*** [Some think we have enough]
Grocery store
Hardware store
Theater/arts complex, plays other arts
Light industry – no smokestacks, pollution, not heavy
Tourism: agriculture part of, people come to Quabbin, stop and spend money
Group #19
* Must support local business, business directories
* Adhere to look and feel of area
Small business [50 or fewer employees]
No major employer [leaving is devastating
Low impact on town [forestry, energy self-sufficiency]
Take advantage of natural beauty/resources
"Tied" to town [responsive to town well-being]
Gardens @ State School
No additional traffic, no tourism, no glut of business
Need business but small
Use existing laws to slow growth
Energy plants utilizing local resources
Means to support goals, determine goals first, then level needed
Grocery store
Where new businesses should be located
Group #2
* Center of town
* State School property [develop both center and State School at same time]
Avoid "Route 9" development
Group #3
* Route 9/Route 202 retail/food/service cluster
Limited cluster – around the existing clusters
Not in my back yard
State School Property
Minimal development, expand space
Specifically zoned – no spot zoning
Architecturally aesthetic
Group #4
* Locations require good thinking. Heavy business on Rte 9/202 maybe.
Planning: type of business is site specific
Avoid environmental problems. Peaceful coexistence.
Can’t have many private employers but no taxes.
Outskirts of town near other town lines
State School property
Need a business friendly environment.
Attitude is not conducive to business at Town Meeting. Stop talking just do it
Somewhere can be hidden from view
Group #5
All in one spot
On the main routes
Two groups: State School grounds & on George Hannum Road
Light industry on highways on outskirt of town,
near Mass Pike or on Rtes 21, 181, 202.
Keep trucks from entering center of town
Industrial parks set aside for business such as at the State School
Put in town center bypass and develop business in conjunction with that
Group #6
Where businesses are already located – accomplish without congestion
Locate in convenient area – not all around
Group #7
*Outskirts of main business area [villages]: south end of Rte 202, west end of Rte 9
Spaces adjacent to existing development
Out of sight, set back
decentralized
Near existing infrastructure
Aesthetics match the neighborhood
Reuse degraded areas
Group #8
* On major road, not central
State School – planned community
Down by Daniel Shay’s Highway, Jabish Brook
Route 9 by Ware
Amherst/ Route 9
Add to existing area rather than something new
Non-polluting light industry, technology based Route 9 area
Group #9
NIMBY!!!
Neighborhood store ok
Go where services already exist
Go where properly zoned
Broup #10
*Architectural value of buildings
* No destruction of virgin land
Route 9, 202, Center of town
Central location
Business in small neighborhood, satellites of common
Keep where they are
Develop around town certain areas, no spot zoning
Home based businesses permitted
Group #11
Not all business needs to be near major highway.
Why not have an industrial park at the State School?
Group #12
* State School
Pockets parts of town
Outskirts of town
Small pockets
Least environmental impact
Across from CVS 9 & 202
Rail trail – small business associated with that
Industry in State School
Group #13
Set aside property for business development
Small businesses located in Common/State School area
Group #14
State School
Sports in old fabric place
Town Common
Walking trail around Town Common
Keep current building that is now Catholic Church
Group #15
* Industrial business in existing locations
Predeveloped areas
Expand from current infrastructure
Commercial but not industrial in 9/202 corridor, join 9/202 corridor – Town Common
bypass e.g. Austin/Gaughan route
Don’t offer tax incentives for business to locate
Group #16
State School grounds
Central locations
Properly zoned areas
Near railroad & main routes
With infrastructure
Groups #17 & #18
State School campus good for arts complex
State School property for light industry. Why aren’t we using that? It has great electric
Facilities, railway, etc, rewired to be state of the art. Why aren’t we using it?
State School gardens help with tourism
Group # 19
Centralize, business districts
Avoid center of town, increased traffic
What homes contribute to town life
Group #1
Bring people with interests and experience
People committed to community – leadership
Support for schools variety of people
Good architecture in public building
Group #2
* Subdivisions create safe environments
Homes establish a community
New people create diversity
Group #4
More schools, more kids, more taxes but w-edged sword
If built well, neighborhoods, need sidewalks, closeness
Safety, talent, enthusiasm, new people, new ideas, diversity
Character, caregivers [babysitters, workforce, employment]
Group #5
** A place to live
*Sense of community
* Sense of diversity
Multifamily h omes deteriorate rural life
Different level of home values create better community
Diversity of type of home including multifamily homes and affordable homes,
particularly for the elderly
Group #7
* Sense of community [Negatives: net tax loss, pollution/resource use
Support local businesses diminished open space, need services, traffic]
Family life
aesthetics
Group #8
*More diversity
*Share burden of taxes; contribute more taxes to those who own land [due to services]
New homes country like, country sense
Some homes are enormous, not diverse
Homes should be at least $250,000
Smaller houses contribute more to the tax base
Group #9
# Neighbors [Negatives: increased costs, taxes, too many
* Diverse population base children, need for more services, traffic,
Commerce more "citified", decreased open space]
Improves atmosphere [usually]
Group #10
*Sense of community, unity
Group #11
People live in homes [Negatives: overcrowding, loss of open space, noise
Contribute to "look" of town traffic
Tax base – negative and positive
Sense of community
School population
Local economy
Group #12
Kids [Negatives: trash, drain on resources,
People loss of rural life & open space]
Atmosphere – how housing done
Set back
Pride – no bars
Safe town
Appearance
Tax base
Richness
Diversity
Group #13
Community life
Houses that look good with character increase values
Tax revenue?
Group #16
Family
Children
Character
Short term employment [construction]
Stability
Groups #17 & #18
Bring in younger people [Negatives: take toll on infrastructure, demands on
Growth, vibrant services
Type of homes is what matters
Group # 19
Kids are future – treat ‘em right [Negatives: new house w/ kids costs town $
for services
Types of homes that would be good
Group #1
Starters, modest income housing, but not cheap construction or design
Dana Hill-type developments
Developments that leave trees, etc. – plan for this
No strip clearing for housing
School development w/ housing development
Town service development
Senior housing – assisted living housing
Group #2
* Affordable housing/mixed income development
* Cluster developments
* Mixed use developments [less dependence on automobiles]
Standard lot sizes – large, minimum 1 acre
Shouldn’t be any restrictions [within zoning]
Elderly housing
No mobile homes
Development mixed with recreation
Low density housing
Group #4
*Owner occupied, regardless of type
Duplexes if owner occupied
If owned, more care, investment, pride of ownership
Can you legislate owner occupied? Can size of lot dictate?
* Affordable
Rental properties, apartments, middle income homes
Group #5
*More cluster development to bring together neighborhoods with less impact on land
Preferred over spread-out developments
* Single family homes
*Owner occupied rental units [not large apartment buildings], some assisted living
Diversity of types, including multifamily. Growth without tax burden
Mix of multifamily and single family, low priced and high priced
Residential areas away from business areas; minimize overlap
Single family homes, upscale, wage earner price ranged
Group #6
* More alternative forms of housing – empty nesters
Mid and low income alternatives
Zoning varieties
Concern about lowering quality of life with low income hosuing
Assisted living for elderly
Need to see life going on around them, emotional life
Need to reach more
Set houses further back from road
Smaller houses – more efficient
House number signs essential
Single family
Group #7
[No consensus]
With set-asides for open space
Not large tract housing
Affordable
Aesthetically pleasing [don’t use hillsides]
Diverse styles
Built where infrastructure exists
Limit new residential development [compensate land owners?]
Group #8
* Increase lot size
* Elderly housing/ golf course
* Duplex housing – scattered, affordable
Affordable housing but larger lots
Less housing
More homes mean more demands
Group #9
* Single family homes
* Retirement community
Open space w/ cluster development
Victorian
English Tudor
Log cabins
Senior/elderly housing
Condos/community living areas [for retired]
Group #10
* Single family
* Clustered, encourage neighborhood
In-law apartments ok
Do not allow multifamily
Planned development, hidden for environment
Play areas, bring in children
Build on existing infrastructure, increase density in towns
Moratorium on development
Group #11
Political baggage with this question
Don’t want to be exclusive
Don’t want golf course/condos
Don’t want utilitarian, industrial look
Build where type of buildings fit – condos near center, etc
Don’t build for elite only
Quarters for elderly parents
More variety contribute to town life
Group #12
Cluster development & require dev. lots of open space
Dana Woods – family neighborhood
Minimal frontage
Single family better than condos, better for smaller community
Own personality
Do not exclude low income
Opposite cluster--house and space
Respectful of environment
No apartment complexes
No low income housing
Require larger parcel of land, not as many houses
Affordable housing
No trailer homes/mobile home parks
Group #13
Invisible
Smaller/cluster
Cluster/open space
Increase minimum lot size
2 family/condos if in right spot
Group #15
**** Limit housing starts [,115 per year], balance w/ business development
*** Homes with larger lots
* Single family
* Developments w/ open space requirements, other amenities such as trees, stone fences
Traditional New England architecture v. contemporary style
Reuse present homes
Affordable housing
Small development 10 or less w/ open space
Not clear cutting
2 family homes, income properties
Concern about traffic increasing
Encourage home upkeep
Diversity
Group #16
Larger lots
Mixed value and style
Senior housing
Assisted living
Multiple family
Groups #17 & #18
*** Avoid low income housing as much as possible
We need to limit single family homes – take up space
Prefer condos, apartments, multiple dwellings
Stable person/ stable family
Limit on rentals and student housing
Reasonable size lots, big lots are better
What about people who can’t afford single family homes??
How about single parents? Have some mixed development
Keep in balance between single family homes and condos/apartments
Group #19
* Impact fee to developers
* Required open space w/ development
* Cul-de-sacs are good, single family only
No condos
Eco-village communities [self-sufficient development, use only local materials]
Larger lot = spread out = more traffic
No Longmeadow or Wilbraham
Local business has burden
Reduce services [unpaved roads]
What is "open space"
Group #1
Nature
Recreation LandUse, Incorporated wildlife
Rural feel
Views and vistas
Group #2
* Conservation areas/wildlife habitat [Quabbin]
Scenic vistas
Common in middle of town
Farms
Undeveloped, natural areas
Recreation land
Group #3
* Town Common, parks
Wide expanses without seeing development
Clear areas to walk dogs without cars
Route 202 Daniel Shays Highway – autumn leaves
Farmland, Hillcrest Orchard [new golf course]
Unpaved natural vegetation, only buildings being agricultural ones, nothing mechanically
cleared other than for agriculture, natural beauty
½ mile between nearest neighbors
Wetlands, Jabbish brook, streams, other running water, forested areas
Forest areas, streams, pond, undeveloped
Group #4
Swamps, woods, fields, brooks, undeveloped land, natural resources
Yes, but the Common is a good example, too
Group #5
Town Common
Forests
Open views
Substantial acreage to find deer, turkey
Lake areas – open to public, recreation
Streams
Undeveloped areas
Reasonable lot size – at least one acre
Soccer field and other ball fields
Farmlands
Wetlands
Active farmlands, cleared forests, maintained recreational lands
Group #6
**Town Common/ ball fields
* Walking Trails
Houses apart/breaks between [woods or fields]
Keep large part agriculture/woodland, open fields
Town sponsored
Group #7
No commercial development
Open undeveloped area
Private control of land use
No residential or commercial development
Nothing man-made on it
Woods, lakes, streams, Sabin orchards
Group #8
* Undeveloped land with recreation access, public/private
*Wonderful/ wood, wildlife around you
Recreation/ sports areas
Large undeveloped parcel
Liability of open/private property
Group #9
* The Common
*Lakes area w/ public access
Forests
Stone walls
Farm lands
Working farms
Recreation areas
Places for long hike
Unobstructed views
Group #10
* Wetland
* 2 kinds: expansive area w/ no structures collectively owned, privately owned
* Areas to go and lean again old oak tree. Peace
Farms, meadows
Do not see your neighbor
Planning for types of housing: trees left to grow natural, woods, open fields
Undeveloped land
Group #11
Natural
Unoccupied by a building
More than 10 acres
"Visual corridors"
No/little human activity. Absence of busy-ness
Distant lights. Can’t see neighbor
It is lost with development
The way it used to be
Large enough for wildlife, etc
Conservation people help, but only zoning can change
Group #12
Large fields
Scenery
Canopy of trees
Woods
Stone Fences
Uncongested Areas
Not a lot of boundaries
Natural environment
Park for playground, picnics
Group #13
* Seeing trees instead of houses
Group #15
Hiking trails
Natural open space
Town Common
Group #16
* Farmland
No development
Farm maintenance
Wildlife
Forest
Rural roads
No commercial development
Large parcels of land
Views
Groups #17 & #18
Town Common characterizes the town – keep it the same
Uncommitted land = open space? Definition
Who owns the "open space"
Farmers who dols their land and broke up open space
Have to respect landowners
Recreational space, land not used for homes. Some areas going undeveloped
Group #19
* Pastures, trees, woods, Town Common, working farms
What open space contributes to town life
Group #2
Town Fair
Aesthetic peace of mind
Recreation
Group #3
Gives people place to go to get away from populated areas.
Relaxes people, so not high strung
Sense of serenity, peace, to get away from constant contact with others as in cities.
General civility, allows to contemplate, meditate, relax
Open space should reduce the tax rate, less things to pay for. Don’t need taxes
Shared viewscape. We all can share it visually at least. Restorative
Peace and tranquility, reflection of rural community.
How the community appears to others
Escape with family in woods, no noise, no cars, retreat. Meet your neighbor,
Friendly atmosphere, brings folks together in civil atmosphere.
Quality of life – peace and quiet. Without open space it would be as quiet.
Important to live in area that is aesthetically pretty.
Group #4
Environmental, water
Sense of relief, freedom
Beauty
Fewer schools [if not developed for housing]
Character
Group #5
Recreational opportunities, good family life
Opportunity to move around, solitary space or recreation, uncrowded land
Feeling of well being, knowing it is there
Formal and informal recreation
Town Common – Fair
Development (housing and/or business)
Sense of freedom and feeling that they are not closed in
Aesthetically pleasing and relaxing
Parks, community places to meet other people
Ability to enjoy solitude
Group #6
Open space gives us calm
Group #7
* Quality of life
Recreation area – regeneration
Wild life
Protection of resources
Privacy
Peace
Fit for children
Appreciation
Lowers tax base
Lowers blood pressure
Group #8
Quality of life
Less polluted lakes
Recreation for kids and adults
Group #9
Stress reduction
Camaraderie
Less air pollution
Sense of community spirit
Space for friendly activities [not shopping]
Reduces size of government
Less hectic
Tranquility
Privacy
Wildlife habitat
Preserve forestry
Topsoil preservation
Group #10
Rural character of town
2nd largest land town for land
Preservation, sense of freedom
Privacy
Character
Places you can go to
Part of community recreation ground
Already started, wildlife habitat
Peace and quiet
Nature
Environmental health
Quality of life – freedom
Group #11
Peaceful
Eases stress [unless you own it]
Quality of life
Recreation opportunities
Habitat for wildlife
Everybody likes it
Group #12
Travel more enjoyable
Relaxing – personality
Not congested
Healthy, happy family life – serene
Defines the meaning of town life
Sense of peace and pride
Group #13
*Nice to know it’s there, cannot be developed
To look at
Group #16
* Mental well-being
Ease to navigate
Recreation
Uncrowded feeling
Separates from city
Agriculture and farming
Civility
Groups #17 & #18
Breathing room, space w/o houses = makes community feel better
Types of open space most important to future of Belchertown
Group #1
Connect open spaces
Use & preserve open space
Open up the Quabbin for recreation
Develop open space for recreation
Conserve water places, e.g. lakes
Tax incentives for preservation/open space
Let nature take its course – some times
Warner Rd near Village Green, condos – low land and stream
Land swap offs to make physical connections between open spaces
Town by-pass in State School
Not clear cutting land for housing development
Group #2
*Farmland
Lake area – town beach
Swift River corridor
Aquifer protection
Recreation areas
Group #3
*Other than public lands, land off roads which we see through our windows.
[Now roads are chopped up with houses; leave curbside more wooded, stone walls
*Town Common, unfortunately ½ a parking lot, more trees, more grass area.
First thing you see, walk the dog there.
A map of all undeveloped land and try to preserve – urban sprawl is destroying the
Character. High density housing. Keep the natural view. Houses everywhere.
What’s happening with the wildlife, environment?
Metacomet Trail – beauty of the scenery. Jabbish Brook North End to South End
It’s not protected, water.
Open space on Old Springfield Road, the lumber treatment plant contaminates, trucks.
Protect that open space
Group 4
*Farms
*Common
* Near Town wells, aquifers, natural resources, gold course
Mill Valley areas
[Are there parcels of big private lands?]
Lakes area
Near Quabbin
South end of town: orchards
State School – develop creatively
Group #5
Tri-Lakes should be maintained and kept for future
Quabbin watershed and Swift River Corridor
Bypass roads so the center of the town doesn’t become a moving parking lot
Existing agricultural land that is not being built on presently
State School land
Woodlands
Recreational fields for kids
Agricultural land
Group #6
State School property – save and reuse, expand in different way
Build off road
Avoid buildings over 3 stories
Group #7
Town Common
Recreation facilities
Agriculture
Woodlands
Protect drinking water
Promote use of Quabbin
Greenways [connected to other green spaces]
Lakes, rivers, streams
Group #8
*Property on Lake Metacomet – St. Hyacinth
* Knight’s Pond area/ Gold Street
Umass Demonstration Forest
Farmlands
Lots D & E, Route 21 wooded area
Private land off G. Hannum
Group #9
*The Common [don’t detract from it]
* The lakes
Woodlands
Farms
Open fields
Preserve the Quabbin
Group #10
* Town Common [contributes to small business]
*Summer concert on Common
Town Fair
Most important is Town Common
* Quabbin
State School property, preserving farm, beautiful view if stays as open space – woods
92 acres of State School where Court House is going – do not develop
Keep open Parcels D & E. Community Center OK, rehab existing structures
Wetlands for environmental and wildlife reason
Bring comfort to people who live here
Group #11
Town Common
Anything that can be maintained as open [economics & political feasibility]
State School as open space
Farms – several by name
Group #12
Rural community – openness maintains the quality
Route 181 – major recreation area
Group #13
* Town Common
M&M Trail
Try to encourage and keep farms
Working forests
Group #15
** Open space purchased by Town to guarantee its conservation
Safe playgrounds, recreation fields
Skate park
Natural resources & wildlife habitat
Water resources – wetlands, streams, lakes
Group #16
* Contiguous with other open space
Effort should be make to preserve any and all
Watershed and aquifer areas
Sizeable woodlands
Ensuring access to other open areas
Open space near existing development and new development
Common and town center
State School farmland
Sizeable roadside setback
Groups #17 & #18
What about the Town buying some open space? How many can we afford to buy?
Off 181
Current farms
On major roads
Issue of road safety with more traffic – need more open space
Wildlife preserves
Group #19
* Protect farms
No golf courses [dissent & debate]
Preserve vistas
Other points raised
Group #1
"Rural" = reasonably sized schools with opportunities to be involved in positive activities [e.g. playing soccer, being in the band], even if you are not the best in the school
Group #4
Franchise makes the suburban feel
Are there ways to support local, unique business?
Is there benefit to center of town being further defined?
How much of Belchertown is currently being farmed??
How much of Belchertown is currently open? Or conservation?
How much of this open land is owned by the Town or the State?
How much land is in Chapter 61 [tax reduction for private agriculture & forest]
Retention of ponds and fields with cluster zoning?
Depends on how they are built? Is land common [open to public]?
Group #7
How do we compensate private landowners for use of open space?
[Conservation easement, purchase of development rights]
Group #12
Concern with number of kids into schools, amazing, burden on taxes & quality
Education
Return the rail trail Amherst through Belchertown
Schools are attractive – keep that way, excellent teachers
Truck route – alternate from middle of town
More Common activity
What can we do to slow down development?
Group #13
Town fund to purchase property (open space)
Group #15
How to keep space open?
Concern with Town Common: 2 upcoming vacant buildings:
Suggestion: possible non-commercial reuse and gathering place
Groups #17 & #18
Should we change business tax rate?
Question about business mix
*** Need for more sidewalks to make open space more accessible and safer,
less need for cars
Issues of the Post Office: confusion
Group # 19
* Agriculture tax rate [encourages keeping open space.
Incentive to maintain open space [tax credit]. Chapter 61 not enough
School tax reduction if 65 years or older
Public must back "good laws" at Town Meeting
Group exercise: making choices and setting priorities. Forum participants were presented with newsprint sheets on the wall which summarized key examples of desired "rural" attributes in Belchertown. These examples were drawn from the Forum’s initial brainstorming about this topic. Each participant received 3 green spots to stick on the points he/she thought are most critical, plus a red spot to place on the point that he/she thought the planning effort needs to be cautious about – that is, that he/she most disagrees with. Please note that there was confusion during the exercise with negative characteristics, especially "no large industry" as explained below. Overall, however, the results of the prioritization exercise show a pattern of areas with general support, and areas where there are more differences of opinion.
The characteristics of "rural" character and the relative priorities awarded by the Forum participants were:
Open Space
[Note: field of green dots ran together between first 2 items, so distribution is approximate]
Farms & working woodlands [48 green]
[Note written on a series of green dots: "Austin’s Farm"]
Conservation lands [40 green]
[Note written on a green dot: "Town fund to purchase open land"]
Parks (some recreation) [13 green]
Active recreation, e.g. sports fields [3 green]
Avoid Pollution
Noise [4 green]
Light [8 green]
Water, air, natural environment [31 green]
Roads
Unimproved [6 green, 20 red]
Few traffic lights [1 green, 4 red]
Views of stone walls & open space [21 green]
Avoid speed on side roads [6 green, 1 red]
New England Style
Town Common [41 green]
Architecture [11 green, 3 red]
Homes
Not big standard subdivisions [16 green, 14 red]
[Note written in: "subdivisions to keep lay of land – no striping of land"]
Not lining the roads [9 green, 2 red]
[Note written on green dot: "Keep open areas"]
Not big apartments [21 green, 6 red]
[Note written on two red dots: "Apts. OK with open spaces"]
Business Development
[Note: confusion regarding whether to put red or green if one wanted to avoid industry;
nevertheless result indicates that there are divergent opinions]
Not big industry [12 green, 36 red]
[Note written on a green dot: "The bigger the better"]
[Note written on a red dot: "No big industry"]
[Note written on a red dot: "I do not want industry"]
[Comment by person sticking on red dot: "Clean industry might be good at the State School"]
Small scale, separate shops & offices [25 green, 13 red]
[Note written next to a green dot: "High tech"]
[Note written next to that: "Yes, great idea"]
Locally owned [10 green, 1 red]
Write in: "No listing or category available for light industry" [2 green]
Town Interactions
Civility [4 green, 1 red]
Safety/know and trust [6 green]
Open Town Meeting [10 green, 3 red]
Site public buildings with respect for neighbors [6 green, 3 red]